Archive for September, 2011

What a week it has been at County Hall.  Chaos reigns while one councillor after another lose their jobs, including both the Leader and the Deputy Leader.

On Monday Dr Andrew Povey, Council Leader, sacked his Deputy, David Hodge, for alleged “differences of opinion.”  On Wednesday Andrew Povey himself resigned claiming that he could not continue being Council Leader whilst also running his health care business (despite having done so for the length of his tenure).   And today, in another parting shot, the resigned leader sacks Cabinet Councillor Ian Lake.

What a state of affairs.  We have a rudderless Council in disarray.  What other professional and efficient organisation of the Council’s size would behave in such a way?  If the Council was a business, would its shareholders be happy about such goings on?  Those shareholders would certainly be seeing the value of their shares plummeting right now.

The truth is that the leadership at Surrey County Council has for some time conducted its business behind a murky cloak of obfuscation.  The Surrey public only sees closedness and reluctance from the Council to open up and listen.  Only recently the Council  refused to consult on on-street parking charges and there has been a similar refusal to consult on controversial library plans.  Thousands of signatures on petitions go ignored; reasonable, intelligent public questions are dismissed or simply go unanswered; considered recommendations of Select Committees just get rejected.  On every issue, the approach at County Hall is to cover everything up and present done deals.

And when the Council feels it has to justify its decisions it uses dodgy data or just gets it plain wrong.  The recent Public Value Review on libraries conducted by County Hall, and used to justify current library plans, is littered with errors. Under pressure from SLAM, SCC was forced to carry out an audit of the PVR.  And according to SCC’s own internal auditors, over 30% of the data and calculations were in error.  The response from the leaders at the Council? “So what, we’re carrying out our plans anyway.”

Surrey doesn’t deserve democracy these days, apparently.  All Surrey gets is decisions made behind closed doors between one or two people at the very top – fait accompli. Don’t like it? Have some reasonable objections? Tough luck!

And then we get the chaos of this week.  No reasons given for the sackings or resignations, just unexplained disarray.  What has been going on at County Hall over the past few years that has led to this pass?  Why the cloak and dagger, why the secrecy, why the lack of openness? The people of Surrey deserve answers.

We think that, to avoid any doubt or suspicion, Surrey County Council should set up an independent enquiry, open and public, to find out exactly what has been going on, the basis for all decisions and to investigate potential conflict in Members’ interests.  If the leaders at Surrey County Council have done nothing wrong then they will have nothing to fear or hide from such an enquiry.

And in the meantime, County Hall should halt its controversial library plans until a clean bill of health is established.  Amidst the chaos that is reigning at Surrey County Council, now is not the time to be making permanent strategic decisions on the library service.


Read Full Post »

The Deputy Leader of Surrey County Council (David Hodge) was dismissed on Monday and the Leader (Andrew Povey) resigned last night.

The library plans and the car parking issues are believed to be the major factors in these events.

We want a massive protest 2pm next Tuesday at County Hall, Kingston – we need everyone there.

  We have already arranged for the press plus photographers to be there at 3:30pm after our questions on the library plans at 2pm.  We have presented more questions than have ever been asked before at a Cabinet meeting.

Take the day off work, cancel your dentist appointment, take friends in your car – tell everyone.  We must stop the library plans – we must stop Surrey County Council – we must act NOW!

Next Tuesday (27th) 2pm at County Hall, Kingston – be there – be there early.

Read Full Post »

Surrey County Council have now made it clear that their “Public Value Review” study was a sham designed to hide their real intent of abandoning most of the small libraries in Surrey to the whim of volunteers.

They have finally declared that they will only properly support 33 libraries and the remaining 19 libraries will have their staff funding removed.  The additional libraries are: Ash, Caterham Hill, Frimley Green, Hersham, Horsley, Knaphill, Lightwater, Shepperton & West Byfleet.

The recent audit into the PVR study said there were 22 “quartiling errors” which apparently gives an error rate of 2.82% – and then goes on to list 29 other errors out of their “sample tests” on 91 calculations but fails to mention that this gives a 31% error rate.  They consider that this level of error means “Some Improvement Needed”.

They also state that the errors do not significantly affect the results, but fail to mention that 3 out of the 13 libraries which should be selected are now excused – 23% are excluded but the PVR study fails to account for these exclusions.

Finally we discover that 19 libraries are threatened, but they bear almost no relationship at all to the bottom libraries “calculated” by the PVR study – which is clearly a deeply flawed farce.  What almost all these libraries have in common is that they have the smallest number of borrowers – we didn’t need a “PVR” study to work that out.

Surrey County Council wish to wash their hands of almost all the small libraries in Surrey and this is their third attempt.  Their first two attempts failed because there was a public outcry by the people of Surrey, so this time they invented a cheap and error ridden “number cruncher” to fool us into believing they were doing it mathematically.

We – and they – know their plans will not make any significant savings and the inevitable closures will cause serious harm to the economic and social life of the affected villages.  We need to let Surrey County Council understand that their attempts to deliberately mislead the councillors and residents of Surrey are unacceptable and undemocratic – their constant claims to be “world class” are looking increasing sad.

Read Full Post »